In Avowed, the side quest 'Fires in the Mine' presents players with a pivotal decision: to either support or stop Darle from blowing up the mine. Both choices come with their own set of rewards, but if you're aiming for the most beneficial outcome in terms of XP, money, loot, and narrative impact, stopping Darle is the superior choice.

Should You Stop or Support Darle in Avowed 'Fires in the Mine' Quest?

Image Source: Obsidian Entertainment via The Escapist

If your goal is to maximize your rewards at the end of the 'Fires in the Mine' quest in Avowed, choosing to stop Darle from detonating the mine is the way to go. While supporting Darle does yield a substantial amount of XP, the total package of XP, money, extra loot, and the narrative benefits you gain by thwarting his plan far outweighs the alternative.

What You Get for Supporting Darle

By supporting Darle and allowing him to execute his plan in Avowed, you'll earn 1026 XP upon completing the quest after speaking with Kada and Seyon. Normally, you'd receive a monetary reward as well, but since this choice jeopardizes the mining initiative crucial for defense against the Dreamthralls, that financial reward is forfeited. Additionally, supporting Darle further strains the relationship between the Aedyrans and Thirdborn, regardless of any attempts to manipulate the truth about the explosion's cause.

Rewards for Stopping & Killing Darle

Choosing to stop Darle in Avowed's 'Fires in the Mine' side quest results in immediate rewards. You'll earn 212 XP for defeating Darle, followed by an additional 879 XP after debriefing with the mining officials, totaling 1091 XP—65 XP more than you would get for supporting him. Moreover, Seyon and Kada will reward you with 900 coins for your efforts.

Before leaving the mine, you can also loot Darle's corpse, which yields the following items:

• Blackwood Branch (Superb Upgrade Material)
• Wild Mushroom Stew (Prepared Food)
• Beetle Pie (Prepared Food) x2

While the food items are minor, the Blackwood Branch is a significant bonus, perfect for upgrading your weapons and armor. Additionally, by stopping Darle, you maintain the positive relationship between the Thirdborn and the Aedyrans, enhancing the narrative experience.

From a gameplay perspective, stopping Darle in 'Fires in the Mine' is the best choice, offering not only greater rewards but also a more favorable impact on the game's story.

Now that you're equipped with the knowledge to make the optimal decision in 'Fires in the Mine', consider exploring all 12 Treasure Map locations to secure exclusive gear. If you're focused on leveling up your godlike character, find out what the maximum level is in Avowed to understand their full potential.